Tucked inside a new federal law meant to speed up project approvals are changes to critical habitat protection that experts say could weaken an already struggling system.
Last week, the federal government tabled Bill C-39, the latest piece of legislation aiming to expedite major projects.
Buried among its many changes are amendments to the Fisheries Act that would allow developers to pay outside parties to make up for habitat loss they caused. Experts say it would undermine a framework already failing to protect dwindling homes for wildlife.
“This is our worst fear,” said Misty MacDuffee, a biologist with the environmental advocacy group Raincoast Conservation Foundation, in an interview with Canada’s National Observer.
“All the concerns we’ve had about the erosion of our environmental laws and the loss of habitat protection for threatened and endangered wildlife, it’s happening. It’s here.”
Currently, developers building a project that damages the environment are required to avoid or lessen the destruction of critical habitats for endangered species. Where that is not possible, they must submit a plan to restore habitat in another area — a practice called “offsetting.”
Right now, developers have to create new habitat at the same time as they build their project, or they can draw from a “habitat bank” made up of credits earned from previous conservation work.
Under Bill C-39, developers will be able to purchase credits from a third party, or, in cases where impacts are judged to be “minor,” pay a simple fee instead.
The Department of Fisheries and Oceans (DFO) did not explain to Canada’s National Observer what qualifies as a minor impact.
“They can just pay their way out of habitat damage. It’s now the cost of doing business,” said MacDuffee.
For MacDuffee, it’s not an abstract discussion. Raincoast has resisted the proposed expansion of the Vancouver port at Roberts Bank for years.
The existing port terminal separates the Fraser River, home to some of Canada’s most important salmon runs, from an eelgrass habitat that juvenile salmon need for shelter and food once they make their way downstream to the ocean. The port is made up of a collection of causeways and piers jutting into the sea south of Vancouver, and already poses an obstacle for young salmon. A second terminal, MacDuffee says, would make that problem worse by vastly expanding the area.
Chinook salmon are the primary prey of the Southern Resident Killer Whale, a critically endangered species that hunts just outside the port. According to recent estimates, only about 73 of the whales remain.
“They’re saying they can offset these impacts in other parts of the Fraser River. That is impossible,” said MacDuffee. “When a salmon has made its way to the estuary, moving back up into the river is going backward. It’s not the direction that fish is inherently destined to go.”
Offsets approved with no regard for effectiveness: experts
Scientists and environmental advocates across the country argue offsetting is being used to enable projects that should be prevented by species-at-risk legislation. Evidence shows that offsets are rarely implemented as proposed and, even when they are, almost never deliver the promised results.
The federal government’s own review confirms the lack of accountability. A report from the Auditor General’s office last year looked at four offsets and found none were progressing as planned.
The audit also found DFO had completed no analyses of the effectiveness of using offsets.
“The department does not know how successful the overall use of authorizations with offset measures has been over time,” read the report.
In Kananaskis, Alta., several offsets have been approved to enable logging in critical habitat for two endangered trout species.
A permit was granted in December for a project requiring 62 river crossings in critical habitat. The alternative — to “do nothing” — was rejected on the grounds that the crossings were needed by the loggers. That’s a common refrain from governments, says Josh Killeen, conservation science manager with the Southern Alberta chapter of the Canadian Parks and Wilderness Society.
“Every single permit that we’ve seen resorts to offsetting,” Killeen said.
“If we’re not even considering other options beyond assuming that things need to go ahead exactly as they are, and then finding a way to permit them through offsetting, then we’re not even really trying to find solutions.”
Another proposal currently under review suggests building offsets in a different watershed than where the project will occur.
“They’re unconnected, and that’s against DFO’s own science guidance, where it says that offset measures should be local wherever possible. And it doesn’t make common sense,” said Killeen.
Kathleen Church, an assistant professor of animal ecology at Missouri State University, was on a team of researchers in 2024 that studied the effectiveness of five offsets in the James Bay area of northern Quebec. The findings illustrated a system she calls “woefully inadequate.”
“We talk about the goal of ‘no net loss,’ but it wasn’t even close, the habitat lost versus what was gained or improved through compensation projects. It’s a huge disparity.”
In each case, applications proposed offsets much smaller than the area that was about to be destroyed, but were approved anyway. And after the offsets were built, Church said there wasn’t enough monitoring to verify that they worked.
In a statement to Canada’s National Observer, DFO said habitat banking allows for restoration work to happen before a development begins, rather than after the environmental impact has occurred.
“When offsetting is done upfront via a habitat bank, it also means that project reviews can proceed efficiently. It is win-win,” read DFO’s statement.
Church agrees that habitat banking helps cut time lags and improves the likelihood that the proposed offset actually works. But she’s suspicious of measures that add more separation between project proponents and the damage they cause.
Fisheries and Oceans Canada told Canada’s National Observer the use of third-party credits will be subject to the same standards that are currently applied, including that the credit is applicable to the same species-at-risk that the project will affect.