Article content
Thursday’s report made the reasons for the decades of hesitation all too evident. While the attractions of a smooth, efficient and comfortable train ride whisking along at 200-300 kilometres an hour offers much to be wished for — not least an alternative to increasingly unappetizing air travel — the hazards are enough to sober all but the most oblivious enthusiasts.
Article content
And while projections advocating for HSR are just that — calculations based on a collection of variables that may or may not occur — the risks are backed by actual examples of real-life disasters. Almost 20 years after it was approved, a California plan to build more than 2,000 km of high-speed line from Sacramento to San Diego hasn’t sold a single ticket amid spiralling costs, repeated delays and abandoned plans. Only a much-reduced segment touching none of the state’s major cities is currently under construction, with completion dates stretched to the late 2030s.
Article content
A similarly ambitious U.K. plan to link London to Birmingham has been termed “Britain’s most expensive infrastructure failure,” with cancelled segments and major cost overruns, including more than 100 million pounds for a special shed to protect bats along the route.
Article content
Article content
The PBO report blithely attributes the U.S. and U.K. problems to “difficulties with land acquisition, permitting, litigation, design changes and project-management weaknesses.” Such things could never happen in Canada of course. Nonetheless — just in case — it notes that Carney’s Liberals have adopted legislation to “mitigate” the risks. All the same, the report insists that “the robustness of these provisions before Canadian courts, as well as their inherent effectiveness in targeting sources of cost escalation, will be a key success factor in mitigating significant project risks of the baseline estimate.”
Article content
In other words, all bets are off until environmental groups, activists and indigenous communities have finished deploying legions of lawyers to stymie as much progress as possible.
Article content
Still, it will take more than compliant courts, satisfied activists, faster permitting, better management and neutralized bureaucrats to overcome the considerable challenges inherent in any effort to bring increased speed to a sclerotic railroad — the realities of geography, for example.
Article content
Article content
“The Canadian Shield represents an important engineering challenge,” the report notes dryly, something builders of the Canadian Pacific Railway noticed 140 years ago. About 130 km of track between Ottawa to Peterborough would cross the shield, it says, requiring extensive rock cutting, grading and filling.
Article content
In addition, joining Montreal to a station in Laval would require a 15-km tunnel under the city. That’s almost twice the distance the Coalition Avenir Quebec (CAQ) government pledged to build under the St. Lawrence river to ease traffic from Quebec City to Levis, a proposal that never manifested, blew up in the CAQ’s face and helped get it ousted from office.
Article content
Delays for this new proposed tunnel, of course, would be pricey: about $1.5 billion a year, while each additional kilometre of the tunnel would add about $169 million, a considerable concern given the PBO questions descriptions of the route as 1,000 km. long, pointing out that the current highway distance is less than 850 km. It says construction would certainly create jobs, but the economic impact would be “modest” and might actually delay other projects due to the labour demands.