Article content
The committee said “grave concerns and deep divisions” continue to exist. A recurring theme was the pressing need for better access to mental health services and concerns long waits for care could exacerbate suffering, driving MAID requests. The committee also heard stories of “questionable conduct” by some MAID providers, as well as doctors “with a seemingly cavalier attitude toward ending a life,” committee co-chair Liberal MP Marcus Powlowski wrote in a supplemental opinion.
Article content
However, the committee’s decision wasn’t unanimous. Three senators as well as a Bloc Québécois MP, Luc Thériault, wrote dissenting opinions and called on the government to bring the question of expansion to the Supreme Court of Canada.
Article content
After Fraser’s announcement, Conservative MPs blasted the move as playing politics as the House of Commons was set to vote on a bill they said did substantially the same thing the government was now promising to do.
Article content
They also criticized Fraser’s decision to bundle the issues of MAID for mental illness and allowing for advance requests in the same bill.
Article content
Article content
“What the minister has announced today is eroding that consensus and introducing division into a very complex subject,” charged Conservative MP Andrew Lawton. “We agree that MAID should not extend to people with only a mental illness.”
Article content
Earlier this week, Fraser told reporters he’d heard “a range of different views” since the committee’s report was released in June and that he wanted to take the time “to line things up the appropriate way” in deciding on such a serious issue.
Article content
First legalized in 2016 for people whose deaths are “reasonably foreseeable,” Canada’s MAID law was amended in 2021 to remove the “reasonably foreseeable” provision. The amendments under Bill C-7 also included a restriction on mental illness alone as a qualifying condition for MAID, an exclusion that was originally set to expire on March 17, 2023, but was later pushed back to 2024 and then a third time, to March 2027.
Article content
Currently, dementia is an eligible diagnosis for MAID in Canada, provided people have the capacity to make a reasoned request and don’t lose that capacity before they want their lives ended. Dementia is considered a neurological disorder, not a mental illness.
Article content
Article content
Canadian children’s author Robert Munsch revealed in a New York Times profile last year that, shortly after being diagnosed with dementia in 2021, he applied and was approved for MAID.
Article content
Munsch said he would have to pick the moment “when I can still ask for it,” otherwise his wife risks being “stuck with me being a lump.”
Article content
Outside Quebec, euthanizing someone in the absence of capacity is a serious offence in the absence of a valid waiver of final consent.
Article content
The new bill will amend the Criminal Code to reflect that a doctor who provides MAID to someone who is suffering an incurable illness and who has complied with provincially legislated safeguards “will not be treated as a criminal in Canada going forward, ” Fraser said.
Article content
Alex Schadenberg, executive director of the Euthanasia Prevention Coalition, said the concept of consent becomes challenging under advance request scenarios, because someone else will have to decide when the person is experiencing conditions under which they would have wanted their lives ended.
Article content
“It’s really a problematic situation, and then who makes the decision in the end? Some family member, some doctor who says, ‘Oh, I guess this was requested in the end,’” Schadenberg told reporters on Parliament Hill Wednesday.
Article content
“To me, it’s almost very eugenic.”
Article content
National Post
Article content
cnardi@postmedia.com
Article content
Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark nationalpost.com and sign up for our politics newsletter, First Reading, here.
Article content