FIRST READING: The eyewatering cost of the projects Canada is pitching to investors

Article content

First Reading is a Canadian politics newsletter curated by the National Post’s own Tristin Hopper. To get an early version sent directly to your inbox, sign up here.

Article content

TOP STORY

Article content

Article content

This week saw Prime Minister Mark Carney preside over the first-ever Canada Investment Summit, a large, Toronto-based gathering of international financiers. At the centre of the summit was a “pitchbook,” outlining a slate of pre-approved projects open for investment, most of them resource-based.

Article content

Article content

The projects are also incredibly expensive, with several proposals dwarfing anything that’s ever been built in Canada with private capital.   

Article content

Article content

High prices aren’t all that off-brand for the Carney government. Its 18-month tenure has been marked by a series of big-ticket purchases that are not just expensive, but expensive beyond all existing standards for what such a thing should cost.

Article content

The Liberals are continuing to pursue a high-speed rail project through Ontario and Quebec that is projected to cost up to $90 million per kilometre. In Europe, such a railway would come in for just $40 million per kilometre.

Article content

And just this month, Ottawa earmarked $4.7 billion for Via Rail to build 313 passenger cars – about $15 million per car.  For comparison, just a few months ago, Siemens signed a deal with the Swiss government to supply up to 200 six-car passenger trains at a cost equivalent to C$3.4 billion. That’s closer to a unit cost of between $2.8 and $5 million per car.

Article content

Below, a quick guide to some of the priciest items in the summit’s pitchbook, along with context about what kind of infrastructure money that represents.  

Article content

Article content

Port of Churchill expansion
Quoted price: $80 billion (US$57 billion)
What that could buy instead: 16 St. Lawrence Seaways

Article content

Article content

The single most expensive item in the Carney pitchbook, the Port of Churchill expansion, carries a capital cost more than twice as large as the entire annual budget of the province championing it. This year, Manitoba will ring up about $27 billion in total expenditures.

Article content

A Government of Canada description of the project notes that the expansion would prioritize “Indigenous equity ownership,” and is a plan to upgrade the port with an “all-weather road, an upgraded rail line, a new energy corridor, and marine ice-breaking capacity.” The last point being particularly important, as the port is currently frozen in much of the year. The idea is to make it an all-weather port.

Article content

As megaprojects go, one of the most successful in Canadian history is usually cited as the St. Lawrence Seaway, a system of canals and locks completed in the 1950s that connected the Great Lakes to Atlantic Ocean freighter traffic for the first time. And even when adjusting for inflation, the total cost of the seaway comes to about $5.3 billion. Or, about 17 per cent of the quoted Port of Churchill expansion price.

Article content

Wind West
Quoted price: $61.3 billion (US$44 billion)
What that could buy instead: Quebec’s largest hydro dam x 6

Article content

The Nova Scotia government is billing Wind West as both Canada’s first “offshore wind development” and the key to making their province “an energy superpower.” It’s basically a plan to install enough wind turbines in a particularly windy area off Nova Scotia to equal 40 gigawatts of power – about a quarter of the electricity that Canada is drawing at any one time.

Article content

Although, like all wind power, that’s only if the wind is blowing. There’s also a lot of unknowns for a project that size. Europe has been building offshore wind for decades, and it still has only installed a cumulative 19 GW worth as of 2023.

Article content

As to what kind of energy project $60 billion could fund instead, it would cover the construction cost of the largest hydro dam in Quebec six times over. The Robert-Bourassa generating station was built for the modern equivalent of about $9 billion in the 1980s.