Geoff Russ: French nationalist Marine Le Pen would be the anti-extremist choice

Article content

Having absorbed much of the traditional French right and left into his centrist government over the past decade, Macron’s party has left very little political energy outside Le Pen’s national right and Mélenchon’s extreme leftism.

Article content

Indeed, keeping nationalists out of government has been a unifying objective of the European Union’s political establishment. Elections in the bloc have frequently ended with unpopular legacy conservatives, social democrats, liberals and Greens forming disparate coalitions to keep the nationalists at bay.

Article content

The nationalists often win a large plurality but cannot find coalition partners to form a parliamentary majority. That might have been a good strategy if those unnatural anti-nationalist alliances could produce effective and transformative governments, but they haven’t. Those rickety governments cannot agree on how to reverse economic stagnation or on taxes, public spending or pensions. All they have in common is the desire to see politicians like Le Pen remain out of power.

Article content

The International Monetary Fund reported in April that European Union industrial energy prices were roughly double their pre-2022 levels. Unstable markets and weak productivity have only worsened the situation, especially for younger Europeans who are disproportionately drawn to the nationalists.

Article content

Article content

In France, for example, one in five young French people is unemployed, and French wage growth stands at less than two per cent annually, well below the European average of 3.4 per cent.

Article content

Furthermore, the rising support for Le Pen’s nationalists reflects more than mere frustration. Mass immigration and the resulting cultural changes are celebrated by Mélenchon but condemned by Le Pen and her allies. Every year, public opinion draws closer to the latter.

Article content

One of the more vexing realities for the European establishment is that voters simply like the policies of their rivals. A poll from last December found that 52 per cent of French respondents and 57 per cent of German respondents considered even legal immigration to be too high.

Article content

The same survey found that majorities across France, Germany and Italy thought most regular immigrants did not share their national values. Questions of character and cohesion are not going away, and the failure of governing coalitions to provide definitive answers is their Achilles’ heel.

Article content

These same voters make distinctions between different categories of immigrants, with legally employed doctors enjoying higher levels of acceptance than those who break the rules. Not only do Europeans want lower immigration levels, but they also want those who are admitted to be skilled and useful.

Article content

Article content

Reluctantly, Europe’s anti-nationalist parties have begun following the trend. Denmark’s progressive government, for example, has become hawkish on assimilation and migration and plans to expel rejected asylum seekers starting in 2027, and the rest of the bloc is starting to follow suit.

Article content

Macron’s minister of European affairs, Benjamin Haddad, has declared that French voters will reject “extremism,” and has called on moderates to rally together and defeat Le Pen once again next year.

Article content

What is not extreme about the current state of Europe?

Article content

Terror attacks have become so normalized that they barely provoke the same outpourings of grief and anger as they did in 2015. In July, a van driven by 21-year-old Abdul Ballout rammed into a Pride parade in Berlin, killing one person and injuring 29. In Canada, there would be state-mandated weeks of mourning, government inquiries, and public memorials. In Europe, it is a statistic.

Article content

Many more statistics of decline could be cited to explain the rise of the nationalists who have yet to govern in most EU member states, from terrorism and migration to basic economic factors.

Article content

Europeans are not insane, and can realize the futility of choosing the same option over and over without results. Their faith in the politics they were raised with is breaking with good reason.

Article content

Most importantly, people across France and Europe are fatigued by a hopelessness from which no bottle of wine or hand-rolled cigarette can distract them anymore.

Article content

If Marine Le Pen is elected, perhaps the French will have indeed rejected the extremism of their times.

Article content

National Post

Article content