Home Active Letters: The secret U.S. plan to invade Canada
ActiveWorld News

Letters: The secret U.S. plan to invade Canada

Share
letters:-the-secret-us.-plan-to-invade-canada
Letters: The secret U.S. plan to invade Canada
Share

Readers comment on a top-secret 1930 American plan to attack Canada, the current trade war, the Belleville synagogue attack, and more

Published Oct 04, 2026

Last updated 40 minutes ago

8 minute read

Top secret package
A top secret 1930 U.S. contingency plan called for the invasion of Canada in the event of war with Britain. The plan was declassified in 1974, relates letter writer Paul Baumberg. Photo by Adobe Stock

Article content

‘Some fact behind this fiction’

National Post

THIS CONTENT IS RESERVED FOR SUBSCRIBERS

Enjoy the latest local, national and international news.

  • Exclusive articles by Conrad Black, Barbara Kay and others. Plus, special edition NP Platformed and First Reading newsletters and virtual events.
  • Unlimited online access to National Post.
  • National Post ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition to view on any device, share and comment on.
  • Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword.
  • Support local journalism.

SUBSCRIBE FOR MORE ARTICLES

Enjoy the latest local, national and international news.

  • Exclusive articles by Conrad Black, Barbara Kay and others. Plus, special edition NP Platformed and First Reading newsletters and virtual events.
  • Unlimited online access to National Post.
  • National Post ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition to view on any device, share and comment on.
  • Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword.
  • Support local journalism.

REGISTER / SIGN IN TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES

Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience.

  • Access articles from across Canada with one account.
  • Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments.
  • Enjoy additional articles per month.
  • Get email updates from your favourite authors.

THIS ARTICLE IS FREE TO READ REGISTER TO UNLOCK.

Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience.

  • Access articles from across Canada with one account
  • Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments
  • Enjoy additional articles per month
  • Get email updates from your favourite authors

Sign In or Create an Account

or

Article content

Article content

Article content

I know there were a lot of disbelieving eye-rolls when people read about Prime Minister Mark Carney’s comment that he had prepared over the past year for the “extreme tail risk” that our southern neighbour might invade Canada, but there’s actually some fact behind this fiction. Back in the late 1920s, the U.S. military developed War Plan Red (formalized in 1930 and declassified in 1974) as a contingency plan in case of conflict with the British Empire. It was part of a series of colour-coded contingency war plans for around the world. War Plan Orange, for example, was for Japan. War Plan Black was for Germany, and so on.

Article content

Article content

Most people agree it was nothing more than a planning exercise, but a key part of War Plan Red was the invasion of Canada. It involved U.S. military operations in Halifax, which would be targeted by a poison gas attack to prevent the Royal Navy from using the port, as well as Niagara Falls (power plants), Montreal, Quebec City, Toronto, Winnipeg (minerals and rail), Vancouver, Victoria, and other locations. For its part, the Canadian government drafted Defence Scheme No. 1, conceived by Lt.-Col. James “Buster” Sutherland Brown, which proposed pre-emptive strikes on a number of U.S. border cities to buy time until support from the British Empire arrived.

Article content

By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc.

Article content

Several years ago, no one with an ounce of sanity would have predicted the current trade war we’re in with our American neighbours, but imagine what kind of stable ground we might be on if someone with forward thinking had asked … what if?

Article content

Paul Baumberg, Dead Man’s Flats, Alta.

Article content

Article content

‘Disgusted’ by CBC’s treatment of Jewish reporter

Article content

Article content

Article content

I am profoundly disgusted with the CBC’s decision to remove veteran reporter Neil Herland from the air after he shared his personal experience of being harassed outside a Yom Kippur service. Penalizing a seasoned professional for sharing his firsthand account of a volatile situation only confirms the CBC has lost its journalistic integrity and has created an extremely unfair double standard.

Article content

Article content

Sandy Besser, Toronto

Article content

Article content

Our national broadcaster’s treatment of journalist Neil Herland, who was doing what good reporters do, even though it was on his own time as he was going to prayer on the Jewish community’s holiest day of the year, was deplorable. The fact that my tax dollars are used to support this kind of unjust bias is disgusting. Mark Carney is enabling Jew hatred in the Liberals’ continued funding of the CBC.

Article content

Marjie Zacks, Markham

Article content

Article content

The left’s disastrous machinations

Article content

Article content

Uncompromising idealists always reveal their authoritarian impulses once in power. Luckily for us, the Liberals’ lust for power has brought them back to the pragmatic middle on economic policy but, the illiberal and divisive progressive left continues to control our cultural institutions.

Article content

The battle for power will continue to rage to the delight of China, Russia and Iran (and Qatar), who will exploit these tensions every way they can. Thankfully, more Canadians are waking up to the disastrous machinations of the left and hopefully, Prime Minister Mark Carney’s necessary defence of liberal democracy and experienced sailing of the economic ship will result in the prosperity, safety and unity Canadians crave. The Conservatives need to make sure this happens.

Article content

Mike Sternberg, Ottawa

Article content

Article content

‘Waiting out’ Trump is not the answer

Article content

Article content

The argument that Canada can simply “wait out” Donald Trump’s trade war deserves more scrutiny.

Article content

Canada may have the fiscal capacity to absorb economic damage. That does not mean Canadian workers, businesses and consumers should be expected to absorb it indefinitely. The people advocating patience are not necessarily the people paying the price for it.

Article content

The costs of waiting are already visible. Delayed investment, disrupted supply chains and weaker demand are not abstract statistics. They affect business decisions, employment and household incomes today. Telling Canadians to remain patient may sound principled from a distance, but economic policy should ultimately be judged by who bears its costs.

Article content

Article content

More importantly, the assumption that time is automatically on Canada’s side is questionable. Some U.S. tariffs reflect objectives that extend beyond President Trump, including rebuilding American industrial capacity, securing supply chains and reducing strategic dependencies. Those pressures are unlikely to disappear with a change of administration.

Article content

Canada should certainly reject a bad deal. But “hold firm and wait” is not an economic strategy.

Article content

The better response is to strengthen what Canada actually controls: eliminate interprovincial trade barriers, accelerate energy and infrastructure projects, reduce regulatory burdens, improve productivity and diversify export markets.

Article content

A stronger Canadian economy would give Ottawa greater bargaining power without requiring Canadians to endure unnecessary economic damage.

Article content

Economic patriotism should not be measured by how much pain Canadians are willing to tolerate. It should be measured by how effectively policy-makers create the conditions for Canadians to prosper.

Article content

Louis-Philippe Noël, Montmagny, Que.

Article content

Article content

Article content

Are provinces willing to lose constitutional powers to the EU?

Article content

Article content

Canada is an experienced confederation of provincial and territorial jurisdictions for almost 160 years. The EU has been confederated only 33 years. Within confederation, Canada’s provinces retain far broader constitutional responsibilities than do EU member states, despite federal efforts to usurp provincial roles. These include a notwithstanding clause, which EU member states do not enjoy. Are Canadian provinces and territories willing to see Ottawa put up for auction their long-defended constitutional roles?

Article content

What the EU and Canada do seem to have in common right now are supremely over-reaching leaders, who have both chosen not to consult in any way their respective provinces, territories and states. If this were more than political grandstanding, they would have worked maturely through our respective long-serving confederal institutions, and tabled options before our respective parliaments.

Article content

John L. Riley, Mono, Ont.

Article content

Article content

Olivia Chow’s actions are ‘no surprise’

Article content

Article content

That Olivia Chow did not participate in a recent mayoralty candidate debate about antisemitism and the safety of her city’s Jewish community came as no surprise to any of us who have paid attention to her record since taking over city hall in June 2023. Her excuse (that she was not officially campaigning until the day following the debate) was simply too lame to be taken seriously.

Article content

Since Oct. 8, 2023, Chow has unabashedly supported the anti-Israel mobs on our college campuses and public spaces by failing to take action (other than condoning the Toronto Police, who at one point provided coffee to these useful idiots). She joyfully marches with the LGBTQ, Caribbean and myriad other cultural communities that make up Toronto’s mosaic, adorned in the appropriate costume of said group (taking a page out of the Trudeau family’s notorious India junket). She has been noticeably absent from the annual Walk with Israel, the Jewish community’s equivalent celebration of their pride in their heritage.

Article content

Article content

In contrast, we heard clarity from Belleville Police Chief Murray Rodd, who has been unequivocal about the actions of two of his brave police constables in responding to the attack on Sons of Jacob Synagogue. They were there to “serve and protect” and no doubt saved the lives of all those who were in synagogue to pray on our holiest holiday.

Article content

While our municipal politicians do not identify with a particular political party, Chow (and her late husband, Jack Layton) have been long-standing NDPers. In the company of disgraced former MPP Sara Jama and recently elected leader of the federal NDP, Avi Lewis, she is a staunch supporter of the same party that federally criticized the Liberal government for adopting the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s (IHRA) definition of antisemitism.

Article content

Jews make up less than four per cent of our city’s population, yet their contributions to the medical, legal, educational and cultural sectors belie their small numbers. The Jewish community does not expect “special treatment” from our political leaders, simply to be given equal standing with all citizens and protection against the hateful aggression and desecration of Jewish institutions, which we have publicly witnessed for nearly three years. While I agree with most of Howard Levitt’s comments, we already “have the answers” from Chow.

Article content

Article content

Susan Silverman, Toronto

Article content

Article content

Avi Lewis’s comments ‘out of the Middle Ages’

Article content

Article content

NDP Leader Avi Lewis’s comments about atonement and collective responsibility of Jews for genocide are straight out of the Middle Ages and that’s where they belong.

Article content

The timing of those comments, tweeted a mere hour after the attack on the Sons of Jacob Synagogue in Belleville, in which a massacre was only narrowly averted and Const. Jeff Smith was critically injured, compound the disgust I feel about them.

Article content

Frank Feldman, Toronto

Article content

Article content

Show support for Jewish Canadians

Article content

Article content

It is disgraceful that Jewish facilities must hire off-duty police as guards, when that is the function of publicly funded police forces. Police boards and commanders must deploy their services where they are needed.

Article content

Canada is shamed when Jews are afraid to wear their symbols in public. I suggest that all Canadians, of whatever religious belief, buy a small Star of David and wear it in defiance of those who assault us.

Article content

Charles Hooker, East Garafraxa, Ont.

Article content

Article content

The eve of destruction?

Article content

Article content

In 1965 singer Barry McGuire recorded a song titled “The Eve of destruction” (written by P.F. Sloan) that prophesied the destruction of the human species. Recent news that the United States has weapons orbiting the planet should be a stark wake-up call for all people on Earth. Combine this grim news with the recent revelations from experts that artificial intelligence poses an “existential threat to mankind” and we have a double-barrelled threat facing us. It certainly does little to allay our fears to know that much of our world is controlled by a few despotic rulers.

Article content

In light of all this, one is reminded of Mark Twain’s quotation: “I believe that our Heavenly Father invented man because he was disappointed in the monkey.” However, to end on a more positive note, we turn to the words of Alexander Pope: “Hope springs eternal.”

Article content

Bob Erwin, Ottawa

Article content

Article content

National Post and Financial Post welcome letters to the editor (250 words or fewer). Please include your name, address and daytime phone number. Email letters@nationalpost.com. Letters may be edited for length or clarity.

Article content

Article content

Article content

Article content

Share
Related Articles
opposition-says-wa-should-not-be-included-in-national-gas-reserve-scheme

Opposition Says WA Should Not Be Included in National Gas Reserve Scheme

The federal opposition is marking its turf on plans to create a...

greens-elect-former-mp-mike-morrice,-the-sole-candidate,-to-lead-party

Greens Elect Former MP Mike Morrice, the Sole Candidate, to Lead Party

Newly elected Green Party Leader Mike Morrice points as he speaks at...

breast-milk-can-be-lifesaving-for-premature-babies,-quebec-charity-says

Breast Milk Can Be Lifesaving for Premature Babies, Quebec Charity Says

When Annie Sicotte gave birth to her first daughter 11 weeks early,...

is-autumn-glow-the-next-winx?-inside-the-making-of-a-racing-superstar

Is Autumn Glow the Next Winx? Inside the Making of a Racing Superstar

Autumn Glow now has six Group 1 victories—and she is fast becoming...