After dodging a number of difficult questions since the start of the campaign, the leaders of the five main political parties were forced to answer several of them in a playful setting on the set of the popular Sunday night talk show, Tout le monde en parle.
Christine Fréchette held up the “against” card when host Guy A. Lepage asked the candidates to say whether they were “for or against Quebec independence” as part of a kind of rapid-fire quiz.
Earlier, however, during a more formal interview, the leader of the Coalition Avenir Québec (CAQ) had declined to give a straight answer to the question, as she had done since the beginning of the campaign.
“We’re staying in the garage; we don’t want a referendum,” she said, referring to the buses representing the “yes” and “no” camps in a potential referendum campaign. “We don’t want a referendum. Seventy per cent of Quebecers don’t want a referendum. And God knows that having a referendum in the next term would create even more uncertainty,” she said.
As he did during Wednesday’s Radio-Canada debate, Paul St-Pierre Plamondon maintained that there would be a “right moment” for Quebecers to decide on their future within Canada.
“I think the government that succeeds the CAQ will have a lot of work to do, and that the situation with the Americans also involves a lot of work,” he said. “But there will be another time to ask ourselves whether we deserve, like all peoples around the world, to have our own democracy and to be masters in our own house.”
One federalist, two sovereigntists and two sovereigntists in “airplane mode”
In response to Conservative leader Éric Duhaime, who touted the advantages of “having a strong position” within Canada and forging “alliances with the other provinces,” St-Pierre Plamondon said that the “autonomist approach proposed by Mr. Duhaime is the same thing as the CAQ.”
“Changing the name Legault to Duhaime doesn’t mean the doctrine […] is going to work,” he thundered.
For his part, Quebec Liberal Party Leader Charles Milliard argued that he was the only true federalist in the group. “I’m one of those who believe Quebec should continue to grow within Canada. Obviously, that’s not the case with my colleagues. We have two avowed sovereigntists here, and two sovereigntists in airplane mode.”
The party leaders were asked to identify their top priority:
Duhaime: “Lowering taxes for taxpayers. […] Leaving more money in people’s pockets: $1,170 per household.”
Ruba Ghazal: “Controlling rents […] so that people can live with dignity.”
Milliard: “100,000 housing units a year.”
Fréchette: “Reducing the cost of living in every way possible.”
St-Pierre Plamondon: “Putting an end to CAQ waste and reinvesting those funds in urgent issues such as homelessness.”
Hijab, street prayer and toll fee
The “for” and “against” card game also gave viewers a chance to see St-Pierre Plamondon hold up neither the “for” nor the “against” card when asked about wearing the hijab in public — a headscarf worn by Muslim women to cover their hair, neck and sometimes shoulders — just hours after speaking out against school-parent volunteers wearing religious symbols.
The co-leader of Québec Solidaire, Ghazal, was the only one to hold up the “for” card when asked whether she supported or opposed street prayers.
Duhaime, meanwhile, was the only one on the “against” side when it came to restrictions on screen time for young people under the age of 16.
The Conservative leader was also the only party leader to say he supported using artificial intelligence to improve a political speech. He said he had used AI to find comments made by St-Pierre Plamondon about the proposed third link between Quebec City and Lévis.
Viewers also learned that Milliard, the Quebec Liberal Party leader, supported road tolls.
Finally, the five leaders were asked to identify their greatest strength and biggest weakness:
St-Pierre Plamondon: “Authentic / Stubborn as a mule”
Fréchette: “Determined / Not always punctual”
Ghazal: “Big-hearted / Argumentative”
Duhaime: “Persistent / Emotional”
Milliard : “Good listener / Annoying”
The Quebec elections will be held on Monday, October 5.