Rwandan imprisoned for hate speech fails in bid for Canadian intervention

Article content

A Quebec judge has dismissed the case of a former senior Rwandan politician who was deported from Canada and ended up in prison for his role in the central African country’s genocide more than three decades ago.

Article content

Léon Mugesera, 74, is serving a life sentence in Rwanda for hate speech aimed at stirring up killings of minority Tutsis in the early 1990s. Canada deported him to Rwanda in January 2012.

Article content

Article content

Article content

He took Attorney General Sean Fraser to Federal Court claiming that his “fundamental rights are being violated in his homeland, and that Canada has the duty to intervene with the Rwandan government in light of the diplomatic assurances received prior to his removal from Canada.”

Article content

Article content

Justice Denis Gascon concluded in a recent decision out of Montreal that Canada owes Mugesera nothing.

Article content

“Canada did not and does not have an ongoing obligation to monitor the way the Rwandan authorities have been treating Mr. Mugesera since his removal from Canada,” Gascon said.

Article content

“Given the absence of any obligation on Canada in this regard, the court is of the opinion that Canada’s conduct did not contribute to the violations of fundamental rights that Mr. Mugesera claims to be suffering at the hands of the Rwandan authorities in Rwanda.”

Article content

About 800,000 Tutsis and moderate Hutus were killed by extremist forces in the regime, then dominated by Hutus, in 1994 over a period of 100 days.

Article content

Mugesera, a university professor and influential politician, made a speech in 1992 that incited the slaughter of the minority Tutsis. He fled the country, arriving in Canada in 1993 as a permanent resident, along with his wife and five children. But his status was revoked and he was ordered deported in 1996 when authorities learned he wasn’t forthcoming on his application form when entering Canada. His wife is a Canadian citizen and still living in Canada, according to Gascon’s ruling.

Article content

Article content

Mugesera appealed the deportation order all the way to the Supreme Court, which ruled unanimously in 2005 that there were reasonable grounds to believe he had committed crimes against humanity.

Article content

Article content

It then took six years for the Canadian government to assess the risk to Mugesera’s life if returned to Rwanda.

Article content

When Canada again ordered him deported in December 2011, Mugesera’s lawyers, convinced their client had no chance of a fair trial in Rwanda, turned to the Federal Court, Quebec Superior Court and the United Nations in failed last-ditch efforts to keep him here.

Article content

In April 2016, the Rwandan high court convicted Mugesera, who had been a regional vice-chairman in the ruling party, of genocide and crimes against humanity.

Article content

Mugesera has since alleged that his “physical and moral integrity was undermined many times by the Rwandan authorities,” that his “conditions of detention constitute mistreatment,” and that “he received death threats from and was regularly humiliated by the Rwandan authorities, which contributed to his psychological distress,” according to the Federal Court decision.