Five European countries announced a joint plan on Monday to send rejected asylum seekers to a return facility in Rwanda.
Under the arrangement, which is still under negotiation with officials in the Rwandan capital of Kigali, Denmark, Austria, Greece, Germany, and the Netherlands would relocate individuals who have exhausted their legal options to remain in the European Union.
Once there, the migrants would have the option to return to their countries of origin, settle in Rwanda, or move to another location where they hold a right of residence, according to statements from Rwandan Minister of the Interior Dr. Vincent Biruta.
Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen called the concept a potential “game changer” at a press conference in Vienna, alongside Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker and ministers from the other participating countries.
She said the initiative would better equip governments to confront the substantial challenges posed by illegal immigration.
“Today marks a crucial step towards a new migration system. A system that safeguards the cohesion of our societies and answers the concerns of our citizens,” Frederiksen said.
Stocker in his comments at the press conference labeled the move a “paradigm shift in migration policy,” saying nations and the EU must be “masters of our own house.”
“Because if people without the right to remain in the EU cannot be removed from the country, our entire asylum system becomes absurd. We will not allow this. If the state sets limits, then these must be respected,” he said.
“If return to the country of origin is not possible, then people without the right to remain will in the future be returned to a third country—such as Rwanda.”
Biruta said that his country’s motivation for participating in the scheme was “about contributing to a solution to a global challenge.”
The Rwandan interior minister stressed that most of the people sent to the return hub will likely choose to return to their countries of origin, but those who did choose to stay “will be integrated into our society and our own communities will benefit from that integration program.”
“These people we are talking about, these illegal migrants who will be relocated to Rwanda, are not going to be kept in a camp or in a dedicated area; they will be integrated into our society,” he said.
According to a statement from the Danish government announcing the move, the aim is to make the first transfers of migrants to the hub in 2027.
The effort forms part of a wider EU drive to accelerate the removal of people without lawful status and to limit irregular arrivals, and follows the recent adoption of the EU’s new Return Regulation, which is intended to speed up deportation procedures.
Human Rights Groups Object
In a joint statement, 47 organizations spanning aid agencies, trade unions, and rights groups urged the five countries to abandon the Rwanda plan.
The signatories, which include the International Rescue Committee and the Dutch Council for Refugees, argue that the proposal signals acceptance of the risk of serious human rights violations against a highly vulnerable population in exchange for a deterrent effect that available evidence indicates is unlikely to materialize.
“Such cruel measures drive people into further insecurity, and risk making migration routes more dangerous,” the statement reads.
Amnesty International separately labeled the move “disgraceful” and accused the participating countries of “repeating the mistakes of the past.”
“Sending people to a country they have never been to is irresponsible, and there is a real danger that the Rwanda deal will, with its limited chance for scrutiny, become a cruel black hole for human rights,” the group said.
Previous Rwanda Plans
The United States began transferring migrants to Rwanda last year under a separate agreement that permits the deportation of up to 250 people.
Washington has struck deals with multiple African countries, and some Latin American nations, allowing it to deport illegal immigrants to those nations if their home countries refuse to take them back.
The UK announced a plan to deport migrants to Rwanda in 2022; however, that scheme became tied up in legal turmoil for years, with the UK Supreme Court eventually ruling that the plan was illegal under human rights law.
The plan was completely abandoned after the 2024 UK general election that saw the Labour Party oust the ruling Conservative Party, which had held up the “Rwanda Plan” as flagship policy.
The European plan differs in a key respect from its UK forerunner in that it would apply only to people whose claims have been fully rejected and who have no remaining legal avenues inside the EU. The nixed British plan also applied to individuals whose applications were still under review.